Saturday 31 May 2014

JBL S300a review

If you have spent much time in the world of audio, then JBL is a name that you will definitely have heard of. JBL is world renowned for making great audio equipment. If you don’t know JBL started out JBL was founded in 1946 by James B Lansing after leaving his previous company. The company was originally called Lansing Sound Inc., but was later changed to James B. Lansing sound. However it wasn’t until 1955 the company changed its name to the brand JBL after long standing disputes with Altec Lansing. The original company name "James B. Lansing Sound, Incorporated" was retained but the logo had to be changed to the JBL logo we all know today.
JBL was bought in 1969 by the then named “Jervis Corporation”. We now know it as Harmon International. In the 70’s JBL expanded into producing studio monitors and in 1977 they were being used by more recording studios than all the other brands combined. Over the next 20 years JBL began to move into the mass market with consumer loudspeakers and the more exclusive market of concert speakers, cinema speakers and then the automotive industry.
In modern time JBL now also manufactures wireless speakers, headphones and audio docks. It just shows that JBL moves well with the times and is always on point with what the market trend is doing.
Now we have had a brief history lesson can begin with the review. So as previously mentioned JBL manufacture headphones and todays review is all about a pair of headphones they make, they are the JBL Synchros S300a.

Specs and in the Box
·        On-ear design
·        Premium 40mm driver
·        JBL PureBass performance
·        Frequency response of 10Hz to 22kHz
·        Max SPL 115dB @ 30mW
·        Power input 30mW
·        3.5mm connection
·        3D rotational fold up design
·        Steel headband and leather ear cushions
·        Currently priced at £129.99 (UK)

In the box

·        S300 headphones
·        Comes with one three button universal remote for Android, Blackberry or Windows
·        High quality carry case
·        Manuals and quick start guide

Accessories
Like mentioned in the section above you get an included carry case. The case is very nice, small enough to fit in a bag and will provide decent protection against light knocks and scrapes. The case is very nice quality, not 100% sure what material it’s made from but it is very soft to the touch and smooth. The case is semi-rigid meaning it’s not a hard carry case and not a soft one, it sits in middle. A best of both worlds you could say. The case included with the headphones is black and features the JBL logo on one side and the Synchros logo on the other. Inside the case is lined with a very soft felt material and includes a section to store the cable whilst in transport. Overall it’s a nice carry case that will provide ample protection but just be sure that if you do pack them away for travel don’t place heavy items on top as the case isn’t a hard shell and will still squash under a heavy load.  

Aesthetics
The S300a are quite a masculine headphone, they are quite rugged looking and this actually suits the headphones very well. They are available in Black and White, both are equally nice with the white looking the more modern of the two. The headphones ear cup features a large JBL branded logo that sits in the middle of a circular steel disk. The ear cups also feature a lovely mirrored cut out, this gives the appearance of being semi open-back, however it’s just a design feature that actually looks quite nice and really adds something to the quite stripped back design.
From the disk the support arms split and form a quite lovely support for the headphones. This then joins seamlessly to the headband. On the connection between the two you get the Synchros logo in grey. The headband is really quite nice and one of my favourite design features of these headphones. The band is made from stainless steel and includes a numerical system that allows you to see the headband adjustment; the headband also again features the JBL logo printed across it. The headphones themselves are covered in a quite nice matt finish which feels quite nice. The finish unlike some does not attract the usual dirt and grease usually associated with this type of finish. I found that when they did get a bit dirty they wiped clean quite easily, leaving no visible marks. The rugged design of the headphones can also be seen by the exposed bolts used in the hinge mechanism of the headphone. This could have easily been covered but I like the fact that it’s exposed. The headphones look a bit bulky, with the thick support arms and connection between the support and the headband, but they are actually not that large in size.
Overall they are a quite nice looking headphone if you like the more rugged industrial look.

Build quality
Like their design their build quality is very substantial as well. With use of premium materials such as Steel and Leather, they incorporate materials usually only reserved for higher priced headphones. Yes they do contain plastic but it’s not cheap or poor quality like some other headphones at this price point. The plastic featured isn’t rough and cheap feeling, it’s quite smooth to the touch and feels like a higher quality than what I am used to seeing on similar priced headphones.
They are a quite robust headphone, which is shown in the materials used and the quality of the construction. Like mentioned the construction is very solid and the headphones just feel like they have been put together very well and would probably survive a few knocks without any major issues. Even the folding mechanism feels well-built and it has a satisfying click when being folded up or down. The headband is well made, although quite thin (I presume to save weight) is very strong and doesn’t feel like it would break very easily.
The ear cups and headband padding is very nice and very good quality leather, which I did not expect at this price. I was expecting synthetic leather but to get real leather is a real treat. The feel is very nice; it’s very smooth and quite plush. There is quite a substantial amount of padding on both and is just an overall unexpected nice touch.
The cable is also nice, it’s quite thick and is very well made. There are no issues at the attachment points and it generally feels good. The controller is nothing special but it’s again well-made and will last in use. The buttons have a nice feel to them, which is reassuring as you can be sure that it won’t break any time soon.
If I was to point out one weakness it would be the folding mechanism, though very well made its likely to be the first part of the headphone to break. I think that’s testament to how well the rest of the headphone is made. However the aforementioned life of the folding mechanism depends on if you are going to be folding them down a lot. But again folding mechanisms generally are the weak points of most folding headphones and JBL have made the best I have ever tested so that again is reassuring.

Comfort
There is a lot of scope for sizing and they should fit even if you have a small or larger head, this is thanks to the headbands sizing mechanism. Although not a unique design I find that getting the sizing right is quite easy.
Now this is where the negative aspect of the headphones comes in. Although the headphones are very light and the clamping force is just about right, the ear cushions design is not good. It’s not the padding it’s the shape. The ear cups are circular and just an awkward size. It’s kind of weird, the size is a bit bigger than on ear but smaller than over ear (yes I know that sound odd, but you can see in my video review what I mean). This just renders the soft padding kind of useless as the ear cup is just wrong (for me). The design like mentioned is circular whereas I think an oval or over ear design would have been much better. I even tried to fix this by adjusting the headband but then the ear cups didn’t sit right and to be honest I got a bit fed up of trying to find the right position for listening.
So they are not very comfortable at all, the most I can spend listening to these headphones is about 20 minutes before they become unbearable to wear anymore. However you may find that they suit you better. I think JBL could have done a better job and seen that circular design ear cups (unless over ear) are just not that comfortable and if a headphone is uncomfortable the likely hood is that you are not going to use them. Comfort really is important because if headphones are uncomfortable then you can’t enjoy them for extended use.

In-use and issues
In use they are pretty great (well apart from the comfort). They are very light and the included carrycase makes them ideal for travel. They fold down to about the size of my hand, which is about average for a UK male, so that’s not overly large (again you can see the demo in the review). They fit around your neck quite nicely and aren’t obtrusive in that respect. The cable is nice and is just the right length to retain their portability. The functionality of the remote is a breeze and a welcome addition to the over-populated iOS controls. The volume up and down buttons actually work on most Android, Blackberry and Windows devices, which for me is awesome as I now don’t have to keep taking my phone out to adjust the volume. The middle button takes care of most of functions, the list of these functions are as follows….
1 press to play/pause or to answer calls
2 presses and you go to your previous track
3 presses and you go to the next track
So overall functionality of these headphones is the best I have ever used as I am an Android user and all the best headphones seem to just be for iOS. The fact that JBL included a universal controller is just frankly awesome and I think more headphone makers should follow suit and do the same.

Now to the issues, like I mentioned comfort is the main issue, but there are two more.
1.      The way the headphones look when you wear them. Again you will have to watch the review to see what I mean, but I will try to explain. When wearing the headphones I found that the ear cups stick out far too much and there is quite a large gap between your head and the headphones. This really makes the headphones look quite awkward when on and buts a dampener on the really nice design. 
2.      The microphone and call quality. This is just not good, during testing I was told that the microphone was a bit distorted and sounded quite unnatural. Now I wasn’t expecting amazing clarity or a really realistic sound, but this was quite terrible. To make my point I am currently reviewing another set of headphones at half the price of these and the mic is much superior quality. Also the sound through the speakers is again not good, it was bit distorted and crackly. So I thought I will try it on another phone and it was the same again. However it’s not inaudible but just not nice and is all a bit disappointing and to be honest I expected a bit better.

Isolation and noise leak
Noise isolation on the S300 is quite impressive. Although very uncomfortable to wear I found that they blocked out quite a lot of background noise on the bus where I tested them mostly. They did a really good job a preventing the dull drone of the engine as well as peoples conversations and outside traffic noise. Only the louder noises made it through. So considering they aren’t noise cancelling they performed better than expected. Noise leak again is quite impressive, with them only really leaking audible noise at around ¾ volume, which when on public transport you can’t really notice. In the house where it’s quiet obviously the noise leak is more noticeable but nothing unbearable to people close to you. So here the S300 really do score well. They are actually I would say joint first with the Audio Technica ATH-M20x that I tested a few weeks ago.

Sound quality
To talk about sound I first listened to the headphones with a flat equalizer to really get to know what the headphones sound like without any tweaks. The first thing that really hit me was the bass, now even on a flat eq the bass was fairly deep, punchy and had a lot of presence. The bass is very controlled but not over tight, the bass reproduction doesn’t muddy the rest of the sound and just really works with the sound rather than trying to take control. The low end has a lot of detail especially when listening to music with a good bassline, however the S300 aren’t like your artist inspired headphones that tend to add bass for the sake of it just to add a bit of vigour to the sound. The JBL has the same deep bass but it never ruins anything and I think it’s all down to the JBL Professional Audio Sound which includes PureBass performance.
This enhancement really goes a long way to improve the lower frequencies and to always ensure that it never steals the limelight and just enhances the experience rather than hindering it.
The Mid-range is again well produced with bundles of detail, control and are also very accurate and on point. The mid-range can easily be distinguished and just doesn’t sit muted in the background. I know this next bit may sound like a contradiction but although the mid-range has its moment to shine in the foreground, but it can come off a touch cold. Yes I know I said it’s not muted, it’s very clear and present just cold. There is no real warmth or energy to the mid-range which can leave you feeling a little disheartened. Don’t get me wrong the mids are great and work well, but for me they just didn’t add to the overall wow factor of the sound. Maybe an alteration to the equalizer will bring out the best in them.     

Vocal reproduction is very solid and quite nice. I listened to a few live sets from Foxes and the vocals where amazing. You could really hear every intake and every exhale of breath and her voice sounded wonderful. On music that’s been tweaked the vocals again are very strong, but for some reason I found that they always seem to sound better on live sets. I’m not sure why but that’s what I experienced. So in terms of vocal reproduction I am actually very impressed, the only headphones I have heard sound better in terms of vocal reproduction are the Bowers & Wilkins P3, which frankly are amazing and the JBL where closer than I would have expected.

Now testing the headphones on my equalizer settings on the Rocket Player on my Nexus 5 (which see the bass adjusted slightly, the mid-section increased a bit more and a slight adjustment to the higher end) and things get better. The bass pretty much stays the same, but it’s the mid-range that sees the biggest change. The mids now are improved, they still have the same detail but the signature just warms slightly. It’s still slightly cold but better. So I tired increasing the mid-section again and found they became too overpowering, so I set them back and it was better.
Overall I really like the sound of these headphones and they are very good, I just wish the mid-section had more about it.  

Summary
To wrap up the review, I would really like to say that I liked the sound of these headphones. I know I said the mid-range is cool but as a whole the sound quality is good. I quite like the styling and the build quality is top notch, the only things that really let the headphones down are
1.      The comfort
2.      The way they look whilst wearing them
3.      The mic and call quality
but other than that they are really good headphones. If you can find a position where they are comfortable, don’t mind the slightly awkward look when wearing them and the quite poor call quality then these are good headphones. Maybe the above won’t bother you but for me, I could live with the slightly awkward look and the poor call quality, but the deal breaker for me is the comfort. They really are that uncomfortable and maybe they will be alright for you but for me I just couldn’t cope with them, which is a shame because apart from the few flaws and the major flaw, they are very good.

To watch the unboxing and review click the links below.


To see for videos from me check out the link to my channel.

Thanks for reading guys.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment